The Phins Draft Results

[Aqua4Ever04]

We held our draft today, here's the results. Who do you think has the best squad?

Aqua4Ever04

QB Ben Roethlisberger
WR Larry Fitzgerald
WR Steve Smith
WR Joey Galloway
RB Brian Westbrook
RB Jamal Lewis
TE Heath Miller
W/R Jonathan Stewart
K David Akers
DEF Tennessee

BN David Garrard
BN Ahman Green
BN Jerry Porter
BN Ahmad Bradshaw
BN Mark Clayton
BN Mercedes Lewis

Desides

QB Drew Brees
WR Roy Williams
WR Donald Driver
WR Bobby Engram
RB Frank Gore
RB Willis McGahee
TE Dallas Clark
W/R Chester Taylor
K Stephen Gostkowski
DEF Seattle

BN Jay Cutler
BN Jerious Norwood
BN Robert Meacham
BN Shaun Foster
BN Reggie Brown
BN Michael Bush

Phunwin

QB Carson Palmer
WR Dwayne Bowe
WR Bernard Berrian
WR Patrick Crayton
RB Joseph Addai
RB Maurice Jones-Drew
TE Antonio Gates
W/R Fred Taylor
K Jeff Reed
DEF Jacksonville

BN Julius Jones
BN Kevin Smith
BN Donte Stallworth
BN Leon Washington
BN Matt Leinart
BN Dominic Rhodes

like2god

QB Tony Romo
WR Marques Colston
WR Hines Ward
WR Derrick Mason
RB Marion Barber
RB LenDale White
TE Kellen Winslow
W/R Bryant Johnson
K Nick Folk
DEF San Diego

BN Kenny Watson
BN Owen Daniels
BN Jon Kitna
BN Drew Bennett
BN Cedric Benson
BN Phil Dawson

Boik14

QB Matt Hasselbeck
WR Chad Johnson
WR Kevin Curtis
WR Jerricho Cotchery
RB Steven Jackson
RB Edgerrin James
TE Tony Scheffler
W/R Michael Turner
K Josh Brown
DEF New York

BN Deon Branch
BN Ted Ginn
BN Chris Brown
BN Ronald Curry
BN Jamarcus Russell
BN Tampa Bay

GridIronking34

QB Philip Rivers
WR Torry Holt
WR Roddy White
WR Santana Moss
RB Clinton Portis
RB Marshawn Lynch
TE Tony Gonzalez
W/R Reggie Bush
K Rob Bironas
DEF Indianapolis

BN Anthony Gonzales
BN Alge Crumpler
BN Justin Fargas
BN Jeff Garcia
BN Darrell Jackson
BN Jeff Garcia

BuckeyeKing

QB Tom Brady
WR T.J. Houshmandzadeh
WR Wes Welker
WR Chris Chambers
RB Earnest Graham
RB Deuce McAllister
TE Jason Witten
W/R Ricky Williams
K Kris Brown
DEF Arizona

BN Rashard Mendenhal
BN Nate Burleson
BN Devin Hester
BN Ray Rice
BN Jason Campbell
BN Green Bay

Slickj101

QB Marc Bulger
WR Andre Johnson
WR Greg Jennings
WR Laveranues Coles
RB LaDainian Tomlinson
RB Laurence Maroney
TE Vernon Davis
W/R Willie Parker
K Nate Kaeding
DEF New England

BN Jake Delhomme
BN Issac Bruce
BN Reggie Williams
BN Greg Olsen
BN Kevin Jones
BN Neil Rackers

PhinBeck

QB Derek Anderson
WR Randy Moss
WR Calvin Johnson
WR Javon Walker
RB Ryan Grant
RB Brandon Jacobs
TE Jeremy Shockey
W/R Ronnie Brown
K Shayne Graham
DEF Chicago

BN Matt Schaub
BN Ben Watson
BN Warrick Dunn
BN Ryan Torian
BN Josh Scobee
BN Baltimore

Finole

QB Donovan McNabb
WR Braylon Edwards
WR Santonio Holmes
WR Marvin Harrison
RB Adrian Peterson
RB Matt Forte
TE Zach Miller
W/R Sidney Rice
K Mason Crosby
DEF Houston

BN Selvin Young
BN Chris Johnson
BN Aaron Rodgers
BN Steve Smith (NYG)
BN Desean Jackson
BN Steve Slaton

Alen1

QB Peyton Manning
WR Terrell Owens
WR Brandon Marshall
WR Plaxico Burress
RB Rudi Johnson
RB Thomas Jones
TE Todd Heap
W/R Vincent Jackson
K Adam Vinatieri
DEF Minnesota

BN Tatum Bell
BN Donald Lee
BN Mushin Muhammed
BN Lorenzo Booker
BN Josh Cribbs
BN Pittsburgh

Vengeful Odin

QB Eli Manning
WR Reggie Wayne
WR Anquan Boldin
WR Lee Evans
RB Larry Johnson
RB Darren McFadden
TE Chris Cooley
W/R Felix Jones
K --empty--
DEF Dallas

BN DeAngello Williams
BN DJ Hackett
BN Vince Young
BN Randy McMichael
BN Ladell Betts
BN Kolby Smith

[BuckeyeKing]

Let it be known PPR(Point per reception) is enabled

:D

[GISH]

Let it be known PPR(Point per reception) is enabled

:D

you have the best team. and you should consider starting mendenhall over deuce. he's gonna be a TD vulture.

[Aqua4Ever04]

Nothing personal, Maj, but I don't see how his team is best with Graham and Deuce as his runners.

I do like that 3rd receiver, though. :up:

[GISH]

Best Quarterback
BuckeyeKing - Tom Brady, Jason Campbell

Runner-up: Alen1 - Peyton Manning


Best Wide Receivers
Finole - Braylon Edwards, Santonio Holmes, Marvin Harrison, Sidney Rice, Steve Smith, Desean Jackson

Runner-up: BuckeyeKing - T.J. Houshmandzadeh, Wes Welker, Chris Chambers, Nate Burleson, Devin Hester


Best Runningbacks
Boik14 - Steven Jackson, Edgerrin James, Michael Turner, Chris Brown

Runner-up: GridIronKing34 - Clinton Portis, Marshawn Lynch, Reggie Bush, Justin Fargas


Best Tight End
Phunwin - Antonio Gates

Runner-up: like2god - Kellen Winslow, Owen Daniels


Best Kicker
BuckeyeKing: Kris Brown

Runner-up: Boik14 - Josh Brown


Best Defense
Alen1: Minnesota, Pittsburgh

Runner-up: like2god - San Diego


Best Bench
Boik14 - Deon Branch, Ted Ginn, Chris Brown, Ronald Curry, Jamarcus Russell, Tampa Bay

Runner-up: BuckeyeKing - Rashard Mendenhal, Nate Burleson, Devin Hester, Ray Rice, Jason Campbell, Green Bay


Best Overall
BuckeyeKing

Runner-up: Boik14

[GISH]

props to GIK for drafting Jeff Garcia twice.

[GISH]

Nothing personal, Maj, but I don't see how his team is best with Graham and Deuce as his runners.

I do like that 3rd receiver, though. :up:

he's top 3 in pretty much every category.

[alen1]

Way to embarrass me guys LOL. That draft was a nightmare, ask BK about it, he'll tell you I was bitchin' the whole time.

[Aqua4Ever04]

he's top 3 in pretty much every category.

Based on your rankings, I guess. But running backs win leagues and he doesn't have a top 15 guy there. Also, I don't see the love over Housh, Welker and Chambers.

I'd much rather have Larry Fitzgerald, Steve Smith and Joey Galloway.

[Aqua4Ever04]

Okay now that I look at it again (sorry for tooting my own horn) but how did I not make your receiver list? Fitzgerald and Smith are both top 5 receivers and Galloway has been great in Tampa Bay.

[alen1]

LOL ^^

Aqua is pretty upset about his ranking.

[Aqua4Ever04]

I think people take a lot of credit away from Steve Smith. The Panthers quarterback situation was worse than ours last year and he still had 1000 yards. If Delhomme stays healthy, he'll go back to his old self.

[alen1]

I think people take a lot of credit away from Steve Smith. The Panthers quarterback situation was worse than ours last year and he still had 1000 yards. If Delhomme stays healthy, he'll go back to his old self.

Not only that, he now has two receivers on the opposite side of him that can actually make a play.

[BuckeyeKing]

I know I don't have the best set of runners but I make up for that with WR's that get targeted alot and the top Fantasy player last year.

[Aqua4Ever04]

I know I don't have the best set of runners but I make up for that with WR's that get targeted alot and the top Fantasy player last year.

I think it's unrealistic to think TJ and Welker will both have that many catches again.

[BuckeyeKing]

you have the best team. and you should consider starting mendenhall over deuce. he's gonna be a TD vulture.

Well plenty of time to do that. I probably leave Mendenhall in at the Flex all the time.

[BuckeyeKing]

I think it's unrealistic to think TJ and Welker will both have that many catches again.

I think Welker will have an other great year, Thats Brady's favorite target all game. TJ probably wont but he is their number 1 WR.

Aqua I like your Wide outs just not the Runningbacks.

Edit-I thought you had McGahee and Lewis :lol:

[Regan21286]

I like Aqua's starters. Solid all around. Depth-wise could use a little tinkering. I would definitely recommend he scour the FA lines once the season starts.

[GISH]

I think it's unrealistic to think TJ and Welker will both have that many catches again.

why is that unrealistic? is it more realistic to think that any of your WRs can do that? None of them have a Qb worth speaking of. Galloway is old. Both Fitz and SS are injury prone. To me, I'll take the WRs in their prime with QBs that are on top of the game.

and it's not like i dissed your team. i picked the top 2. is #3 really that bad?

[Aqua4Ever04]

I think Welker will have an other great year, Thats Brady's favorite target all game. TJ probably wont but he is their number 1 WR.

Aqua I like your Wide outs just not the Runningbacks.

Edit-I thought you had McGahee and Lewis :lol:

Moss is Brady's favorite target. TJ is not the #1, Chad is.

And yeah, I took Westbrook 2nd overall. :up:

[Aqua4Ever04]

I like Aqua's starters. Solid all around. Depth-wise could use a little tinkering. I would definitely recommend he scour the FA lines once the season starts.

I made a mistake with Garrard. I figured I need a quality backup because of Roethlisberger's injury problems. Still, depth was incredibily hard to come by because of the amount of teams and positions.

[Regan21286]

I made a mistake with Garrard. I figured I need a quality backup because of Roethlisberger's injury problems. Still, depth was incredibily hard to come by because of the amount of teams and positions.

True. Not sure who else was available when that picked rolled around but I'm sure in Roesthlisberger's bye week or possibly injury you can find a suitable replacement in FA. Pretty much hope either Garrard gets to pass more (unlikely) or a guy breaks out (Henne? McCown? Beck? Croyle? Edwards?).

[HardKoreXXX]

Slick has LT and Maroney. Pretty solid backs and Wr's IMO. If Marc Bulger can be even a shadow of his former self hes got a chance to have a nice fantasy season.

[GridIronKing34]

props to GIK for drafting Jeff Garcia twice.

That's because he's that good...

[Boik14]

Phinbeck, Phunwin, and Buckeye have solid teams...I also like my own team.

[Vengeful Odin]

My team's awesome because I zoned out and didn't bother to get a Kicker.

But I think Phil's team is probably the best. Mainly because he took every player Desides was targeting, which was awesome.

[Desides]

No votes, no nominations, no runner up status in any category.

You're all just jealous that I nabbed McGahee in the 2nd.

[alen1]

No votes, no nominations, no runner up status in any category.

You're all just jealous that I nabbed McGahee in the 2nd.

I am! I wanted him. :cry:

[BuckeyeKing]

Moss is Brady's favorite target. TJ is not the #1, Chad is.

And yeah, I took Westbrook 2nd overall. :up:

Both their 112 receptions says otherwise. :wink2::up:

[Desides]

I am! I wanted him. :cry:

Everyone on my roster is available for trade.

[Desides]

But I think Phil's team is probably the best. Mainly because he took every player Desides was targeting, which was awesome.

And vice-versa. We had alternating picks, so I took someone he wanted and he took someone I wanted. Started with McGahee, continued with Jones-Drew, Dwayne Bowe, and Patrick Crayton.

But he can have Joseph "Shows Up For 12 Games A Year" Addai. :up:

[alen1]

Everyone on my roster is available for trade.

I don't have anything to give you. My teams sucks lol.

Btw, who was the other person who voted for my team?

[slickj101]

Stupid piece of **** yahoo :angry:

[alen1]

Stupid piece of **** yahoo :angry:

:lol:

[MonstBlitz]

Isn't it a little early to be drafting fantasy teams? As things stand now I like this team the best -

Slickj101

QB Marc Bulger
WR Andre Johnson
WR Greg Jennings
WR Laveranues Coles
RB LaDainian Tomlinson
RB Laurence Maroney
TE Vernon Davis
W/R Willie Parker
K Nate Kaeding
DEF New England

BN Jake Delhomme
BN Issac Bruce
BN Reggie Williams
BN Greg Olsen
BN Kevin Jones
BN Neil Rackers

If either Bulger or Delhomme can bounce back this year, that team will be pretty much unstoppable with those running backs. Willie Parker should start over Larry Maroney I think.

[alen1]

Lol his was an autopick draft.

[MonstBlitz]

Lol his was an autopick draft.

Wouldn't be the first time I've seen an autopick team win it all! :up:

[BuckeyeKing]

Isn't it a little early to be drafting fantasy teams? As things stand now I like this team the best -



If either Bulger or Delhomme can bounce back this year, that team will be pretty much unstoppable with those running backs. Willie Parker should start over Larry Maroney I think.

I disagree. Willie Parker use to be a top 12 pick he isn't because he doesn't get goaline carries. Maroney is a great back but The Pats hardly run it.

[phunwin]

And vice-versa. We had alternating picks, so I took someone he wanted and he took someone I wanted. Started with McGahee, continued with Jones-Drew, Dwayne Bowe, and Patrick Crayton.

But he can have Joseph "Shows Up For 12 Games A Year" Addai. :up:

It's funny, but I've never before had a draft where my team could have been so easily interchanged with another team. Just about every single guy you took was either the guy I wanted next, or was someone I was seriously considering.

[MonstBlitz]

I disagree. Willie Parker use to be a top 12 pick he isn't because he doesn't get goaline carries. Maroney is a great back but The Pats hardly run it.

LT I think makes up for both the problems with the other two backs. But I have to admit, I was basing my opinion on my league's scoring format which awards RBs 2 points for every 10 yards rushing and a lot of bonuses for yard milestones.

If it's standard scoring, I actually like your team the best. But Earnest Graham will have to play well all season and Deuce will have to stay healthy.

[azfinfanmang]

I would have to say with the exception of McFatten, Vengeful was very very solid inside and out

[BuckeyeKing]

LT I think makes up for both the problems with the other two backs. But I have to admit, I was basing my opinion on my league's scoring format which awards RBs 2 points for every 10 yards rushing and a lot of bonuses for yard milestones.

If it's standard scoring, I actually like your team the best. But Earnest Graham will have to play well all season and Deuce will have to stay healthy.

I think is standard scoring with PPR. I hoping Graham and Deuce will get the goaline carries along with Mendenhall. I took Ricky and Rice in case Brown and McGahee go down, I really like what Im hearing about Ricky.

[slickj101]

Lol his was an autopick draft.

Not by choice. And what the **** kind of an autopick selects two kickers?

[alen1]

Not by choice. And what the **** kind of an autopick selects two kickers?

:sidelol:

[alen1]

Hey! Who voted the second for my team? I voted once. Whose the other one?

[BuckeyeKing]

I dunno I shoulve voted for my team instead of Aquas. I didn't want to be like most of you and vote for myself. :pity:

[alen1]

I dunno I shoulve voted for my team instead of Aquas. I didn't want to be like most of you and vote for myself. :pity:

Who voted for them selves? :whistling:

[Vengeful Odin]

I would have to say with the exception of McFatten, Vengeful was very very solid inside and out

Thanks bro. I got ragged on pretty hard for the McFadden pick during the draft I'm not going to lie, but I believe he's either going to be a superstar in the mold of Adrian Peterson or completely overhyped like Reggie Bush. Since we're in a PPR league, I figured that even if my fears are realized - and he is overhyped - a poor version of Reggie overs value to my team.

[BuckeyeKing]

He is Reggie Bush 2.0 with more fumbles.

[Aqua4Ever04]

I just picked up McGahee and with him and Westbrook in a PPR league, I'd be hard pressed to find any one that is going to beat me. :D

[alen1]

I just picked up McGahee and with him and Westbrook in a PPR league, I'd be hard pressed to find any one that is going to beat me. :D

I will beat you sir!

[alen1]

WTF keeps voting for my team? Their my heros but I'd like to know who they are. Thanks.

[slickj101]

WTF keeps voting for my team? Their my heros but I'd like to know who they are. Thanks.

lol asskissing is certainly in order in that situatuon. My team is no peach but you def owe a few people a thankyou.

[BuckeyeKing]

I just picked up McGahee and with him and Westbrook in a PPR league, I'd be hard pressed to find any one that is going to beat me. :D

Me :D

[DonShula84]

I voted for Boik for the simple fact that he's my coach in the poster draft. If I bring his fantasy drafting skills into question here that could carry over to that. And what would that say about me? It was a question I didnt want to have to ask myself so he gets my vote here!

[GridIronKing34]

WTF keeps voting for my team? Their my heros but I'd like to know who they are. Thanks.

Who is voting for your team? Uhhh try you and your two alias on this website. You think we didn't know about that? Well we will be merging your three accounts very soon. Pretty pathetic. :pity:


:tongue2:

[azfinfanmang]

He is Reggie Bush 2.0 with more fumbles.

Nope, he doesnt have the ability to catch it out of the backfield like Bush.

[alen1]

Who is voting for your team? Uhhh try you and your two alias on this website. You think we didn't know about that? Well we will be merging your three accounts very soon. Pretty pathetic. :pity:


:tongue2:

:lol:

It's a friend, don't worry guys. He's a lurker.

[alen1]

lol asskissing is certainly in order in that situatuon. My team is no peach but you def owe a few people a thankyou.

You have two kickers on your team so be quiet lol.






:tongue2:

[slickj101]

You have two kickers on your team so be quiet lol.






:tongue2:

Not anymore!

[alen1]

Man I love these people on the website! They keep voting for me but I don't know who it is :sad:.

[Boik14]

I voted for Boik for the simple fact that he's my coach in the poster draft. If I bring his fantasy drafting skills into question here that could carry over to that. And what would that say about me? It was a question I didnt want to have to ask myself so he gets my vote here!Solid logic. In this league, like in the poster draft, I think I have the best team :lol:

[alen1]

:woot: I'm leading!

[Boik14]

:woot: I'm leading!Enjoy it now, it will be the last time. :tongue2:

[alen1]

Lol. I really wonder who is voting for me. I'd like to thank them lol.

[Desides]

Solid logic. In this league, like in the poster draft, I think I have the best team :lol:

Bad receiving in a PPR league and 2 defenses... nah. :tongue2:

I'm amazed my team hasn't gotten a single vote, but oh well, winning converts doubters.

[alen1]

I would vote for others (except that BK guy) but I kinda voted for myself the first chance I got so ..... :up:

[Boik14]

Bad receiving in a PPR league and 2 defenses... nah. :tongue2:

I'm amazed my team hasn't gotten a single vote, but oh well, winning converts doubters.3 wr's with over 1100 yards last year is bad receiving? who knew? And Deion Branch, and Ginn on my bench. Awful... :tongue2:

And defenses are a necessity. You play the one with a better matchup. I like the Giants but Im not playing them if theyre playing Dallas and Tampa is playing say Atlanta....

[Desides]

3 wr's with over 1100 yards last year is bad receiving? who knew? And Deion Branch, and Ginn on my bench. Awful... :tongue2:

Chad Johnson is now the #2 WR on that team thanks to Housh's great 2007 and CJ's offseason whining. Kevin Curtis is just one of many targets, and will likely lose catches and yards with a healthy and franchised LJ Smith, a newly-drafted DeSean Jackson, and a newly-acquired Lorenzo Booker ready to go. Cotchery put up so many yards because the running game was totally ineffective; that should be different this time around.

And defenses are a necessity. You play the one with a better matchup. I like the Giants but Im not playing them if theyre playing Dallas and Tampa is playing say Atlanta....

There are better ways to win than streaming defenses.

[Boik14]

Chad Johnson is now the #2 WR on that team thanks to Housh's great 2007 and CJ's offseason whining. Kevin Curtis is just one of many targets, and will likely lose catches and yards with a healthy and franchised LJ Smith, a newly-drafted DeSean Jackson, and a newly-acquired Lorenzo Booker ready to go. Cotchery put up so many yards because the running game was totally ineffective; that should be different this time around.



There are better ways to win than streaming defenses.Its not streaming when you take 2 very good defenses that get a ton of sacks and TO's. Streaming is finding a different one every week. And Ive done that successfully too though I do prefer this method of drafting 2 excellent ones.

If offseason whing drops someone from a #1 to a #2 then T.O. must be #67236 on the depth chart by now. That argument doesnt fly.

Curtis put up similar stats to your boy steve Smith. Hes about as consistent also. The idea that Desean Jackson will take catches from Curtis when hes 4th on the depth chart is funny.

Cotchery i think you have a valid point except that Coles has lost a step and I think Cotchery took the #1 slot from him last year. He was Clemens go to guy an had excellent chemistry with him. IF Clemens wins the job i think he will improve on those stats. If Pennington wins the job i think they'll decline to probably 900/5tds